4.22.2009

Quine's Autobiography

I have been reading Quine's Autobiography. Several passages have so far resonated with me, but the following especially hit the spot.
My study of German in Vienna yielded lavish dividends in Prague, for my dealings with Carnap were in German. It was my first experience of sustained intellectual engagement with anyone of an older generation, let alone a great man. It was my most notable experience of being intellectually fired by a living teacher rather than by a book. One goes on listening respectfully to one's elders, learning things, hearing things with varying degrees of approval, and expecting, as a matter of course, to have to fall back on one's own resources and those of the library for the main motive power. One recognizes that the professor has his own work to do, and that the problems and approaches that appeal to him need not coincide in any very fruitful way with those that are exercising oneself. I could see myself in the professor's place, and I sought nothing different. I suppose most of us go through life with no brighter view than this of the groves of Academe. So might I have done, but for the graciousness of Carnap.

4 comments:

amy katherine said...

Because you have or have not found such a mentor?

Jonathan Charles Wright said...

have not.

brianna. said...

booring.

mclark said...

funny you write about this. lately, it has made sense to me to think that when one is a bright egoist, one has trouble finding authoritative figures respectable, but when one does, one is inclined towards acute obeisance, more so than the average man. and that this too is better. better to laugh at the rare, jem of a joke, than the quotidian quips of queers.